Skeptic hub: six objections, six windows
Placebo, water, mechanism, Lancet 2005, NHMRC, and dismissal sociology — each with what critics get right.
Placebo, water, mechanism, Lancet 2005, NHMRC, and dismissal sociology — each with what critics get right.
What critics say
Each objection is steelmanned before reply.
What defenders reply
Replies separate settled, contested, and open questions explicitly.
What to read next
Pick one objection per sitting with sources open.
ItsHomeopathy presents contested topics without hype: primary sources first, interpretation clearly labelled.